New real crime series has a 92% rating on Rotten Tomatoes


the actual story of a teenage relationship that went awry in Hulu’s The Girl from Plainville

Image credit: Hulu

The Act and The Dropout, two gripping true-crime dramas on Hulu, have long been a go-to for true crime fans. The Girl from Plainville, a new true-crime film, has received amazing reviews and a 92 percent Rotten Tomatoes rating. As a result, we’ve included it in our list of the best new releases to catch this weekend.

The miniseries is based on the actual tale of 18-year-old Conrad Henry Roy III (Coltan Ryan), who committed suicide after a relationship with young Michelle Carter (Elle Fanning) went south. As a result of Carter’s text messages pushing Roy to take his own life, the 17-year-old was found guilty of involuntary manslaughter.


After Roy’s death, his mother (Chloe Sevigny) and father (Norbert Leo Butz) deal with their sorrow and shock in the eight episodes. Enjoys the compassion and interest of fellow students while waiting. However, when the authorities investigate Roy’s death, they discover a cache of text messages that cast a new light on their relationship.

An in-depth look at the Michelle Carter and Conrad Roy case

Conrad Henry Roy III, an 18-year-old high school graduate, was a baseball player, a rower, and a runner at the time of his death. Although he had been admitted to Fitchburg State University, he had opted out of the programme. With his father, grandpa, and uncle in the family’s maritime salvage company, Roy was also able to get a captain’s licence from the Northeast Maritime Institute.

In 2012, while both Roy and Michelle Carter were in Florida visiting family, they met. It was a few years before they saw one other again, despite the fact that they both lived in the Boston suburbs. Text and email communications were the primary means of communication between them. Both teenagers were prescribed medicine for mental health difficulties.


Roy killed himself on July 13, 2014, by inhaling carbon monoxide fumes from his vehicle.

(Image credit: Hulu)

Carter encouraged Roy to commit suicide in a series of text conversations subsequently discovered by police. Once, she recommended utilising the truck’s generator as a backup power source. She wrote to Roy, “I thought you wanted to do this,” when he developed cold feet a few days before his death. You’re at the right place at the right moment; now is the time to act! You can’t go on living like this forever. Do it the same way you did the prior time and don’t worry about it, just do it. To continue doing this on a daily basis is not an option.

Carter was arrested and charged with manslaughter in the wake of the death. Later, the “texting suicide case” trial gained notoriety. Even though she was still just 17 years old when she was arrested, the grand jury indicted her as a young offender instead of a juvenile, allowing for her to be tried as an adult.


Judge Lawrence Moniz of the Bristol County Juvenile Court of Massachusetts decided Carter’s fate after she forfeited her right to a jury trial. In addition to 15 months in prison, she was given a two-and-a-half year term, with the remainder suspended. Five years of probation were also handed down.

Her attorneys took the case to the Supreme Court, saying that Carter’s First Amendment rights had been violated. The Supreme Court refused to take up the matter.

On February 11, 2019, Carter was sentenced to 15 months in prison. Good behaviour prompted her early release on January 23, 2020. Since then, Carter, who is now 25 years old, has avoided making any kind of public remark.


The Girl from Plainville reviews

The Girl from Plainville has a 92 percent rating from critics and a 69 percent audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. “Grounded by a profoundly strong performance, The Girl from Plainville dramatises a horrific true story with elegant restraint,” according to the reviews.

“This recounting of a genuine crime scandal transcends the pop culture frenzy and snappy headlines and strives to depict a real human narrative.”

At Decider, Joel Keller calls The Girl from Plainville “a nuanced look at a dramatic story that played out in the typical media-induced broad strokes.”


Fanning’s “fascinating and frightening” performance of Carter is praised by Vulture’s Jen Chaney, who calls the episode “well-acted but needlessly drawn-out.”

Fanning and Ryan are “impeccably portrayed by Fanning and Ryan,” writes Kristen Lopez of IndieWire.

“Bland” and “more suited to a documentary than a drama,” says CNN’s Brian Lowry of the narrative, describing it as “bland.”


Leave a Comment